Historically, the law has prohibited companies from repurchasing its own shares. There were a number of reasons for this, including shareholder protection. This prohibition protected shareholders against the risk of oppression from majority shareholders and the risk of being underpaid for their shares. Share repurchasing is now permitted and regulated by section 48 of the Companies Act 71 of 2008 (“the Act”). However, how the protection extended to shareholders to protect them from the risk of oppression caused by share repurchases has been unclear under the new system.  The Supreme Court of Appeal recently clarified this position in Capital Appreciation Ltd v First National Nominees (Pty) Ltd and Others (280/2021) [2022] ZASCA 85 (8 June 2022) (“Capital Appreciation”) and clarified that S164 of the Act provides relief to shareholders .

Oppression may occur in circumstances of share repurchasing by a company if minority shareholders are dispossessed of their shares when majority shareholders vote for the company to repurchase minority shareholders’ shares, at a price they did not agree to. The situation forces minority shareholders to sell at a price nominated by the company. In this way, a share repurchase may be coercive and potentially oppressive. The Court in Capital Appreciation has clarified the position and held that these shareholders are, if they have followed procedure, entitled to apply to a court to appraise the value of their shares so that they may be paid a fair price for them.

The contention in Capital Appreciation was whether s164 of the Act applied in the circumstances of a share repurchase. S164 entitles shareholders who dissent to a company’s decision to restructure or enter into a scheme of arrangement (as contemplated in s115 of the Act) to approach a court to have their shares appraised by an expert, to ensure that their shares are bought at fair value. Capital Appreciation was the applicant on appeal and the company seeking to repurchase its own shares. It contended that s164 did not apply as the repurchase of more than 5% of shareholding in the company did not constitute a “scheme of arrangement” as contemplated in S114 of the Act and so S164 was not triggered. Both the High Court and Supreme Court of Appeal were of the opinion that a share repurchase was a scheme of arrangement, but that regardless of this, the fact that the repurchase in question was over the 5% threshold meant that s114 and 115 were triggered. These sections, in turn, triggered s164 as described below.

The Supreme Court of Appeal examined the relevant provisions of the Act, sections 48, 114, 115 and 164, and held S164 of the Act provides relief to shareholders. Specifically, it held that minority shareholders who vote against the sale of their shares (who ‘dissent’) are within the scope of s164’s application. This section entitles dissenting shareholders to apply to a court to determine and enforce the fair value of their shares (to ‘appraise’ their shares).

The Court held that this remedy is available in a specific set of circumstances. First, the company must be proposing the repurchasing of more than 5% of the issued shares of any class. Section 48(8)(b) of the Act establishes that re-acquisitions above this 5% threshold are subject to sections 114 and 115 of the Act. Section 114 places certain obligations on a company wishing to re-acquire its securities. Section 115 deals with the required approval for such re-acquisitions. Specifically, section 115(8) refers to section 164 which provides that holders of voting rights (shareholders) are entitled to have their shares appraised under section 164. They are allowed to do so if: the Company has proposed the repurchase of their shares (which repurchase is of more than 5% of total issued shares), they notified the company in advance of the intention to oppose the Company’s proposal (which decision is conducted by a special resolution) and they have subsequently voted against that special resolution. Such shareholders are entitled to sell their shares (“opt out”) of the company by withdrawing the fair value of their shares, as appraised, in cash.

On finding that s115 of the Act applied, the Court in Capital Appreciation upheld the order by the first court, providing that the shares in question must be appraised by an expert to determine their fair value.

The judgment in Capital Appreciation encourages companies to make reasonable offers for share repurchases, rather than attempting to underpay minority shareholders – knowing that these shareholders may approach a court for appraisal relief under s164 of the Act. However, from a dissenter shareholder’s perspective, the procedure to receive a Court determined fair value is not as inviting as it seems at first blush.

The potential costs of a Court application may deter those shareholders from applying for the appraisal relief. More discouraging, however, is that to qualify for this relief, these shareholders must comply with procedural requirements of first objecting to the proposed repurchase, and then also voting against the resolution for the repurchase. This can be overly burdensome to shareholders who are not aware of this procedure or equipped to timeously follow it.

Additionally, the valuation of shares is not an exact science. It will only estimate a range of values, not a particular figure, and different valuation methods may yield different results. Whilst the Court may employ the assistance of appraisers to determine the fair value for the shares, the risk remains that appraiser’s determination of the fair value may be lower than the shareholder’s estimate of the fair value.

The Court in Capital Appreciation provided valuable direction regarding the appraisal remedy available to shareholders, finding that S164 of the Act provides relief to shareholders. However, this remedy may not be accessible to shareholders who find themselves subject to a repurchase of their shares, as it can often be costly and the outcome may not fit the shareholder’s expectation of the value of their shares. Given these difficulties, we caution companies repurchasing shares and minority shareholders who receive unfavourable share repurchase offers to seek legal advice.

Find out information about our corporate and commercial team here. Business Lawyer | Corporate Attorney | Mergers & Acquisitions | Dunsters Law Firm Cape Town

About the author

Kyle joined Dunsters from Rhodes University in 2021 (B.COM Economics, LLB). He has a multicultural background, growing up between Bahrain, England and South Africa.

Kyle is a strong-minded individual who is passionate about litigation and effectively guiding clients through the legal process.

On weekends you can find Kyle hiking in the mountains or tearing it up on a sports field – his forte being competitive rugby and cricket.

We use cookies to analyse website usage and other technical information to improve the functionality of our website   View more
Cookies settings
Privacy & Cookie policy
Privacy & Cookies policy
Cookie name Active
This policy informs you how we will use your personal information, by using our services and/or website you consent to our use of your personal information for the purposes described herein.
    • Personal Information means information relating to an identifiable, living, natural person, and where it is applicable, an identifiable, existing juristic person, including, but not limited to, name and surname; identification number; physical address; contact information such as an email address and telephone number.
    • Data Subject means the person to whom personal information relates.
    • Responsible Party means a public or private body or any other person which, alone or in conjunction with others, determines the purpose of and means for processing personal information.
    • Identification Information means information that can be used to identify the data subject.
    • Compliance Information means information that is needed by Dunsters Attorneys for us to be compliant with relevant laws including the Financial Intelligence Centre Act “FICA” and regulatory standards and government orders such as Anti-Money Laundering (AML), Know-Your-Client (KYC) and Counter-Terrorist Financing (CTF).
    • Communication Information includes all correspondence such as emails and messages.
    • Financial information means any information relating to payment of invoices, including but not limited to banking information and account details
  • We may collect website usage and other technical information such as details of your visits to our website through cookies and other tracking technologies. Cookies are small data files stored by your computer to help improve functionality or tailor information to provide visitors with more relevant pages.
  • The information we collect may include information provided to us through your initial correspondence, possibly including:
    • Name and Surname
    • Email address
    • Contact numbers; and/or
  • This may also include information that we may have requested, and you subsequently provided, including, but not limited to:
    • Compliance Information
    • Identification Information
    • Communication Information
    • Financial Information
    • Other Personal Information
  • Reasons for collection of your personal information will be explained to you when we collect/request the information. We may request certain personal information to comply with global industry regulatory standards, local regulatory standards or government orders.
  • You, the data subject, consent to our use of your information in line with this privacy policy and/or any terms of engagement you may sign with us. If you wish to revoke your consent, please email enquiries@dunster.co.za .
  • We acquire information from you directly, save where accessible from publicly available sources.
  • Information may be collected through various platforms, including:
    • Our onboarding process with you
    • Email engagement
    • Telephonic engagement
    • In-person engagement
    • Cookies
    • Your personal information may be collected and saved on our system for the following purposes:
      • To enable us to provide legal services.
      • To send news, updates and marketing information.
      • To review job applications.
      • To comply with legal requirements
    • Your personal information will not be used for the following purposes:
      • We will never use your personal information for direct marketing purposes without your consent (you may opt-out of our newsletter at any time)
      • We will never disclose your personal information to another third party without permission from yourself, unless it is required for fulfilment of our legal services or as mandated by law.
  • Right of the data subject under the POPI Act include, but are not limited to:
    • Having access to their recorded personal information
    • Requesting correction or amendment to their personal information and to have information corrected or amended
    • Requesting deletion or destruction of personal information from the responsible party’s system
    • Objecting to the processing of personal information
    • Submitting a complaint to the Regulator regarding the alleged interference with the protection of the personal information of any data subject or submitting a complaint to the Regulator (POPIAComplaints@inforegulator.org.za)
    • Instituting civil proceedings regarding the alleged interference with the protection of their personal information.
  • We will retain your information for the period required by law.
  • Where we retain your contact information for any period other than may be prescribed by law, we retain this information to keep you updated of our various offerings and news. By not unsubscribing from newsletter, you consent to us retaining your personal information on our records indefinitely, for the purposes explained above, including, to keep you informed about news and updates pertaining to Dunsters Attorneys Inc.
  • We take reasonable technical and organisational measures to secure the integrity of your personal information and use accepted technological standards to prevent unauthorised access to or disclosure of your personal information, and protect your personal information from misuse, loss, alteration and destruction.
  • The measures that are taken in order to protect your personal information include:
    • Physical measures: access to physical copies of your information is controlled using strict protocol.
    • Electronic measures: firewalls and password protection
  • While we will take all reasonable steps to ensure the security of your data and personal information according to industry standards, it is not possible to guarantee the complete security of all information provided at all times.
  • We will notify you as soon as reasonably practicable of any breach of security, loss of or damage to your personal information.
  • Data subjects are responsible for taking reasonable precautions to safeguard their personal information.
  • Although we endeavour to ensure your information is as correct as possible, you are responsible for notifying us of any changes to your data or personal information in respect of the services provided and/or your account with us.
  • We will not be held liable for losses of any nature which are due to incorrect data or personal information provided by users in respect of the service provided.
  • We will not be held liable for any loss or damage arising from a security breach or disclosure of your personal information or data, to the maximum extent permitted by law.
  • We shall not be liable for any damage or interruptions caused by any computer viruses or other malicious code that may affect your computer or other equipment, or any phishing, spoofing or other attack.
  • If you suspect that your personal information has been compromised, or that there has been unauthorised use of your email address by any person, or any other violations to the security of the website, please contact us.
Save settings
Cookies settings